Gaulosen Behavioral Findings

Acoustic Monitoring Study - October 2025
Gaulosen Nature Reserve, Melhus, TrΓΈndelag, Norway - October 13-15, 2025
74
Verified Species
4,023
Verified Detections
82.2%
Overall Pass Rate (74/90)
86%
Social Species

Executive Summary

Key Behavioral Discoveries

87% of all detections came from social/flock species, revealing a highly social avian community.

8,778 geese-crow co-occurrences suggest pattern consistent with sentinel mutualism hypothesis where crows act as early warning sentinels for feeding geese.

Extreme flock behavior documented in Graylag Goose: largest event contained 620 calls over 91 minutes.

37 migratory species detected, including active nocturnal migration with 47 flight calls peaking at 03:00-04:00.

Great Snipe migration stopover calling shows dusk timing (20:00-21:00 peak) during autumn migration to Africa.

1. Flock Dynamics & Social Behavior

Extreme Flock Species

Graylag Goose
πŸ“Š 2,871 detections
πŸ¦† 59 flock events detected
πŸ“ˆ 98.7% of calls in flocks
πŸ”Š 59.2 calls/hour (extreme vocal activity)
πŸ† Largest flock: 620 calls over 91 minutes
Flock Species
Pink-footed Goose
πŸ“Š 189 detections
πŸ¦† 18 flock events detected
πŸ“ˆ 71% of calls in flocks
🌍 Arctic migrant
Flock Species Arctic Migrant
Snow Bunting
πŸ“Š 4 detections
πŸ“ˆ 100% flock calling
🌍 Arctic migrant
Flock Species Arctic Migrant

Corvid Flocks

Hooded Crow
πŸ“Š 87 detections
πŸ¦… 10 flock events detected
πŸ“ˆ 69% in flocks
πŸ›‘οΈ Sentinel species behavior
Sentinel Species
Carrion Crow
πŸ“Š 84 detections
πŸ¦… 9 flock events detected
πŸ“ˆ 63% in flocks
πŸ›‘οΈ Sentinel species behavior
Sentinel Species

2. Interspecies Interactions

Corvid-Waterfowl Co-occurrence Pattern

8,778 co-occurrence events detected between geese (Graylag, Pink-footed) and crows (Hooded, Carrion) within 10-minute windows.

Pattern consistent with sentinel mutualism hypothesis: Co-occurrence pattern resembles documented sentinel relationships in mixed-species flocks where sentinel species provide early predator warnings. However, acoustic data alone cannot prove functional benefit.

Mechanism (hypothesis): Potential heterospecific eavesdropping - geese may recognize crow alarm calls. Behavioral observations needed to test this hypothesis.

Scientific Validation

β€’ Magrath, R. D., et al. (2015) - Eavesdropping on heterospecific alarm calls
β€’ King, D. I., & Rappole, J. H. (2023) - Classification of mixed-species bird flocks
β€’ Fallow, P. M., & Magrath, R. D. (2018) - Social learning of heterospecific alarm calls

Mixed Goose Flocks

2,877 Graylag-Pinkfoot co-occurrences suggest regular formation of mixed-species goose flocks.

Benefits: Increased vigilance, collective predator detection, and shared knowledge of feeding sites.

3. Migration Patterns

Nocturnal Migration Flight Calls

47 nocturnal flight calls detected between 01:00-06:00, peak at 03:00-04:00.

Species involved: Pink-footed Goose (18 calls), Common Crane (11 calls), Greater White-fronted Goose (18 calls).

Significance: Documents active nocturnal migration through Gaulosen, likely along established flyway routes.

Migration Categories

Arctic Migrants (10 species)
Pink-footed Goose, Snow Bunting, Whooper Swan, and others
🌍 Breed in Arctic tundra, winter in temperate zones
Arctic Migrant
Long-Distance Migrants (15 species)
Great Snipe (Africa ↔ Arctic), Red-breasted Flycatcher, and others
🌍 Migration routes spanning continents
Long-Distance
Partial Migrants (12 species)
Eurasian Woodcock, Mallard, and others
🌍 Some populations migrate, others resident
Partial Migrant

4. Temporal Activity Patterns

Crepuscular Specialists

❌ Common Grasshopper-Warbler - REJECTED
πŸ“Š 59 detections (FALSE POSITIVE)
⚠️ Rain noise misclassified
πŸ”¬ Spectrogram: Broadband noise, not bird
πŸ“… Seasonally implausible (should be in Africa)
False Positive
Great Snipe
πŸ“Š 189 detections
πŸŒ† 61% crepuscular
⏰ Peak: 20:00-21:00 (82 calls at 20:00)
πŸ›« Migration stopover calling
Dusk Migration
Eurasian Woodcock
πŸ“Š 57 detections
πŸŒ… 75% crepuscular
⏰ Peak: 07:00-08:00
πŸ›« Crepuscular migration calling
Dawn/Dusk Migration

Species Detected Primarily at Night

⚠️ Detection time does not necessarily indicate species ecology - may reflect sampling period

Mallard
πŸ“Š 29 detections
πŸŒ™ 59% detected at night
⚠️ Diurnal species - sampling artifact
Night Detection
Tawny Owl
πŸ“Š 21 detections
πŸŒ™ 48% nocturnal
Territorial hooting at night
Nocturnal
Great Snipe
πŸŒ™ 38% nocturnal
Extended migration calling into night
Nocturnal

24-Hour Activity Timeline

02:00 - 05:00 - Pre-dawn Migration
47 nocturnal flight calls
Pink-footed Goose (peak 03:00), Common Crane (peak 04:00), Greater White-fronted Goose
Active migration through Gaulosen along flyway routes
06:00 - 09:00 - Dawn Activity
Peak dawn calling during migration
Eurasian Woodcock crepuscular calling
Migration stopover vocalizations
10:00 - 18:00 - Daytime Activity
Graylag Goose flock dominance
Peak at 16:00-17:00 (422 calls at 16:00)
Continuous flock calling, feeding, social interactions
19:00 - 22:00 - Dusk Migration Activity
Great Snipe migration stopover calling
Peak 20:00-21:00 (82 calls at 20:00)
Dusk calling during autumn migration to Africa
23:00 - 01:00 - Night Activity
Nocturnal and night-detected species
Tawny Owl territorial hooting, Mallard social calls
Continued Great Snipe migration calling

5. Notable Species Behaviors

Great Snipe Migration Stopover

Detections: 189 total, 61% during crepuscular periods

Peak timing: 20:00-21:00 (82 calls at 20:00)

Behavior: Dusk calling during autumn migration stopover. October = migration season to Africa, NOT breeding season (breeds May-June).

Conservation significance: Declining species across Europe. Stopover site documentation important for migration monitoring and habitat protection.

Important: These are migration calls, not lek displays. Lek behavior only occurs during May-June breeding season.

Migration Context

β€’ October: Great Snipes migrate from Scandinavian breeding grounds to Sub-Saharan Africa wintering grounds
β€’ Dusk calling is common during migration stopovers consistent with migration stopover behavior

❌ Common Grasshopper-Warbler - REJECTED AS FALSE POSITIVE

Original detections: 59 (now rejected)

Rejection reason: Spectrogram analysis revealed rain noise, not bird vocalizations

Evidence:

  • All 3 spectrograms show broadband noise (0-12 kHz), not harmonic bird call structure
  • No characteristic "reeling" trill pattern visible
  • Seasonally implausible (species should be in Africa by mid-September)
  • All detections during heavy rain period

See: GRASSHOPPER_WARBLER_REJECTION.md for detailed analysis with spectrogram images

Eurasian Woodcock Crepuscular Migration Calling

Detections: 57 total, 75% crepuscular

Peak timing: 07:00-08:00 (31 calls at 08:00)

Behavior: Dawn/dusk calling during autumn migration. October = migration season, NOT breeding (roding displays occur March-July).

Important: These are migration calls, not "roding" breeding displays. Roding is a territorial breeding behavior only observed March-July.

6. Habitat Associations

Wetland Dominance

86.6% of all detections from wetland-associated species

Wetland species: 19 species, 3,559 detections

Top wetland species: Graylag Goose (2,871), Pink-footed Goose (189), Great Snipe (189)

Conclusion: Gaulosen functions primarily as wetland habitat with extensive waterfowl and wader activity.

Habitat Guild Distribution

Wetland (19 species)
πŸ“Š 3,559 detections (86.6%)
Geese, ducks, waders, cranes
Forest (9 species)
πŸ“Š 113 detections (2.7%)
Woodpeckers, tits, thrushes
Grassland (8 species)
πŸ“Š 98 detections (2.4%)
Larks, pipits, buntings
Generalist (18 species)
πŸ“Š 338 detections (8.2%)
Crows, gulls, raptors

7. Scientific Context & Validation

Research Foundation

All behavioral interpretations are supported by 26 peer-reviewed scientific sources covering:

  • Heterospecific eavesdropping and alarm call recognition
  • Mixed-species flock dynamics and sentinel behavior
  • Migration patterns and stopover ecology
  • Crepuscular activity patterns
  • Acoustic monitoring methodology
  • Wetland ecology and conservation

Key References

β€’ Magrath, R. D., et al. (2015) - Eavesdropping on heterospecific alarm calls (Biological Reviews)
β€’ Fallow, P. M., & Magrath, R. D. (2018) - Social learning of alarm calls (Current Biology)
β€’ King, D. I., & Rappole, J. H. (2023) - Mixed-species flock classification (Phil Trans Roy Soc B)
β€’ Great Snipe migration ecology and stopover behavior studies
β€’ Radford, A. N., et al. (2024) - Noise constraints on eavesdropping (Biology Letters)
β€’ Complete bibliography: SCIENTIFIC_REFERENCES.md (26 sources)

8. Data Quality & Limitations

βœ… What Has Been Verified

Species: All 74 species verified through manual review of spectrograms and biological verification

Behavioral patterns: Flock clustering, temporal patterns, co-occurrences documented through systematic analysis

False positive removal: 8 species rejected due to biological impossibility (nocturnal woodpeckers, oceanic seabirds inland, seasonal impossibilities)

Verification rate: 82.2% (74/90) overall pass rate through two-stage verification

⚠️ What Still Needs Verification

Detection counts: Only best example per species verified, not all 4,023 detections individually reviewed

Rare species: Species with <10 detections have limited validation

Confusable pairs: Some closely related species may require additional acoustic analysis

❌ Sampling Bias - Cannot Make Weather Claims

IMPORTANT: 80%+ of recording occurred during rain/fog conditions

Impact: Cannot determine if species presence correlates with weather - I only recorded during poor weather

Conclusion: This study documents species detectable during rain, not general weather preferences

Great Bittern lesson: Rain noise caused 129 false positives at up to 91% confidence - highlights challenge of wet-weather acoustic monitoring

Methodology

Detection: BirdNET v2.4 (Kahl et al., 2021) deep learning classifier

Audio enhancement: Wiener filtering + HPSS (Harmonic-Percussive Source Separation)

Spectrograms: Raven Pro-style (2048 FFT, 512 hop length, 0-12kHz)

Verification: Human expert review of spectrograms and audio for all species

Analysis: Temporal clustering (5-min windows), co-occurrence (10-min windows)